55 pages • 1 hour read
A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
Rian reads the captain’s written orders to the crew, which state that the captain is recovering but is still too weak to address them in person. The written orders reveal that the expedition’s true purpose is to find the Sunderlands. They also say that until the captain is fully recovered, she has passed command of the ship to Rian. The next order releases Master Paiyoon from his duties and names Sai as his replacement. Instead of accusing Sai of treachery, however, Paiyoon graciously states that Rian is right to trust her and that nobody could serve her better. He gives Sai his eyeglass and whispers to her that she is more than capable of facing what is to come. He then announces that he is ready to disembark.
At Avens Island, most of the ship’s officers disembark along with Paiyoon, for they are unwilling to take orders from Rian. A large portion of the crew leaves as well, deeming the voyage too risky now that they know a course has been set to cross the Harbinger Sea. Among those who remain are Dr. Pinching, Bo, and Grebe. From this point forward, Sai notices a distinct change in Rian. She is more formal and distant and no longer treats Sai like an equal or even a friend. Although she is not officially the captain, she has fully taken over the role of commander. One day, Sai asks to make a copy of Rian’s silk fishermen’s map, which Rian keeps in her jacket pocket so that she can consult it as needed. Rian refuses, claiming that anyone with a copy could sell it and make a fortune.
The Prosperity attempts to outrun an intense storm but gets caught in it. As Sai tries to get belowdecks, she is suddenly pulled into Captain Sangra’s cabin. The captain claims that Rian has put something in her vitamin drops to keep her weak and sedated. She stopped taking them and is finally starting to regain her strength. She realizes that Rian has charmed Sai just as she has charmed everyone else still onboard. When Sai tells the captain where they are and admits that Paiyoon has disembarked, Sangra declares that they are all truly lost. She reveals her awareness that Rian is her sister and says that Rian’s story about being denied the family’s advantages is false. Sai is tempted to ignore this revelation because Rian has been kind to her and ostensibly wants her to have a better life. Doubt gnaws at her, though, and she asks the captain what the real story is.
The captain says that her father doted on Rian was doted and gave her every advantage, but she also acknowledges that Rian was denied a lineal and the family name. In a sense, their father showered her with gifts while denying her worth. Anchalee and Rian were best friends in college, but things changed. Anchalee gave Rian a fortune to pay off her gambling debts, but Rian always needed more. Although Rian claimed that she worked her way up in through the Navy ranks, the reality was that their father made sure to put Rian under Anchalee’s command in order to protect her. Additionally, Rian never saved Anchalee’s life; the captain just reported it that way in hopes that Rian would finally be satisfied upon gaining her own lineal.
The captain then reveals more of her own story to Sai. She shows a picture featuring her and a man with whom she fell in love while stationed in Amnaj. Sai observes that the man has Bo’s eyes. The man wanted to marry Anchalee, but she refused because she was from a royal family and he was a commoner. They had a son together, and Anchalee left the child with his father and promised to return, but the war went on and on. For years, she sent money to her son’s aunt in Pitaya. She was desperate to get back to her son, but the war always kept her away. Eventually, she stopped getting letters from the boy’s aunt. Rian found out about the son and used the information to extort Anchalee to gain a place on the expedition. The captain tells Sai that she looked for her son when they docked in Pitaya, but she couldn’t find him. Her son’s name was Amanat, but they called him Bo. Right after she reveals this, Dr. Pinching bursts into the cabin, shouting about a fire in the galley.
While Sai goes belowdecks to look for Bo, Captain Sangra helps the sailors who are fighting to steer away from the worst of the storm, but something has damaged the rudder, and it won’t turn. Sai wakes Bo before he succumbs to the smoke from the fire. They return to the deck to find massive waves crashing over them. Bo wraps ropes around their arms to keep them both from being washed away. When they realize that they won’t survive another wave like the last, they rush to get belowdecks before the next one hits. They make it to the first open cabin, Rian’s, just in time.
Sai and Bo wait in Rian’s cabin for the worst of the storm to pass. That night, as soon as she is able, Sai goes on deck to look for Rian or Anchalee. When she looks over the side of the ship, she sees a massive, scaly beast coiled around the hull. Then she blinks, and it disappears. Suddenly, she can feel the ship moving more freely and realizes that the rudder is no longer jammed. Sai resumes her search and finds Rian and the captain fighting each other on the top-deck. The scene is only revealed during the intermittent lightning flashes, but she is nearly certain that she witnesses Rian throwing Captain Sangra overboard.
Without the captain’s protection, Sai senses that she and Bo are in great danger. They hide in the galley behind the cook’s counter, but Grebe finds them. He says that the captain’s disappearance will look like evidence of mutiny, and even if Rian finds a way out of it, the crew will be condemned. He says that the only way to escape punishment is for everyone to stick to the same story and make it look like an accident. Because Sai has pretended to be a high-born snob, the rest of the crew believes that she will not go along with this plan, so they mean to kill her.
Grebe demands the truth about Sai’s background. Sai admits that she is from the Fens, and that her real name is Sodsai Mudawan. Grebe says that he didn’t follow her that night in the Fens to rob her; instead, he was trying to find her father. They had both served time in jail together, and he owed Mud a favor for protecting him from an abusive guard. Grebe promises to pay back the favor now by helping Sai. He says he’ll tell the rest of the crew that he never found her or Bo. He then lowers Sai and Bo down onto a crate floating in the water. Using this as a raft of sorts, they will be able to float to a small island that is visible in the distance.
This section of the novel is marked by a variety of ironic plot twists and meaningful revelations that highlight the theme of Truth, Lies, and Self-Deception from many different interpretive angles. Central to this trend is Captain Sangra’s double revelation that she is fully aware of Rian’s history and motives, and that she is actually Bo’s mother. Her admission of this fact reflects a prime example of both situational irony and dramatic irony, for just as the author intends to surprise readers with the truth of Bo’s parentage, the captain herself remains unaware that her son is currently aboard her ship. Further irony can be found in the fact that Sai’s efforts to help Bo stay hidden have actually hindered the reunion that both he and Captain Sangra have so earnestly sought. Similarly, Sai’s clever deception of feigning snobbery and a high-class upbringing to cover her true background has also created the unwelcome side effect of earning her a reputation for untrustworthiness amongst the crew, and thus, a ploy that was originally intended to ensure her safety now ends up endangering her life.
In addition to these many examples of irony, perhaps the most vital reversal occurs with Captain Sangra’s revelations about Rian’s history and actions. The captain’s version of events makes it clear that Rian’s sympathetic characteristics were merely a deceptive façade designed to gain Sai’s trust. Combined with Rian’s newly distant and cold behavior toward the girl, the captain’s story confirms that Rian is the true villain of the story. However, even as these larger deceptions are revealed, Sai persists in the habit of self-deception, for she is tempted to disbelieve the captain’s story, preferring to believe Rian’s version because it aligns with her own values and ambitions. This inner conflict demonstrates just how subjective a person’s perception of reality can be. However, despite this temptation to continue believing the lie, Sai’s instincts lead her to doubt Rian’s version and seek the truth for herself.
These chapters also continue to create a more nuanced view of Sai’s father, and this recharacterization manifests in several different ways. For example, the revelation of Sai’s real name, Sodsai Mudawan, subtly elucidates why Sai’s father is called Mud. Rather than a demeaning nickname that symbolizes his lowly status, as it initially appears to be, “Mud” is merely a shortened version of his surname. This suggests that his character, like his nickname, contains greater depth than meets the eye, and this impression is confirmed when Grebe reveals that Mud saved his life by protecting him from an abusive prison guard. Sai also learns that helping Grebe earned Mud a broken leg and two extra months of prison time.
This revelation creates a significant twist on Grebe’s character as well, reversing Sai’s initial impression of him, for contrary to her belief, he was never trying to rob her, and he never would have betrayed her upon recognizing her on the ship. Just as she holds a negative view of Mud, she also chose to perceive Grebe as a villain without looking any deeper. The author’s portrayal of Grebe uses Sai’s perceptions to bolster this misconception within the narrative, but when he helps her to escape, his actions challenge Sai’s too-quick judgments about others’ intentions. Grebe’s reason for helping Sai ironically makes Mud himself indirectly responsible for her salvation. She has always blamed Mud for dooming her to a life of suffering, but now, her own actions have put her in danger, while Mud’s past actions have initiated a chain of events resulting in her escape.
Just as the secrets of several characters are revealed, certain characters also undergo crucial moments of transformation, chief among them being Captain Sangra herself. Although she refused to marry Bo’s father because she knew her royal family wouldn’t approve of his commoner status, she now no longer cares about their opinions and is resolved to find her son. In her public life, she is already lauded as a hero for her bravery in the war, but her true heroism and bravery are displayed in this decision to honor her relationship and regain a connection with her family. Her decision also foreshadows her future activism on behalf of Mangkon’s lower-class citizens, for rather than continuing to uphold the empire’s skewed social ideals, she chooses to challenge and revolutionize them.
It is also noteworthy that Chapter 28 takes place in the harbor of Avens Island and is titled “The Edge of the World,” for this stylistic choice imparts the island’s dual symbolic meaning. On a practical level, it is the Prosperity’s last place of port before the expedition attempts to cross the Harbinger Sea. As such, it represents the geographic boundary between the known and the unknown. The “edge of the world” can also be viewed as a metaphorical moral turning point, for it is at this moment that Sai chooses to part ways with her own values, betraying Paiyoon and playing a key role in forcing him off the ship in order to pursue her own interests over the well-being of others. Tellingly, she rationalizes her morally questionable choice through self-deception, just as imperialist conquerors like Mangkon rationalize their exploitation of colonized lands.
Plus, gain access to 8,800+ more expert-written Study Guides.
Including features:
By Christina Soontornvat
Action & Adventure
View Collection
Asian American & Pacific Islander...
View Collection
Class
View Collection
Class
View Collection
Colonialism & Postcolonialism
View Collection
Coming-of-Age Journeys
View Collection
Fathers
View Collection
Juvenile Literature
View Collection
Nation & Nationalism
View Collection
Newbery Medal & Honor Books
View Collection
The Best of "Best Book" Lists
View Collection
Truth & Lies
View Collection