59 pages • 1 hour read
A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
Miller arrives back in California and awaits the call to testify in Turner’s trial. She worries “about not having enough people in the courtroom” (146). One evening, she visits the train tracks near her high school where many classmates committed suicide. She struggles with her desire to end her life; she finds it difficult to imagine a future but knows she “would always get up, turn around, and jog home, because it was the only thing [she] knew how to do” (149).
Miller meets with Alaleh to rehearse her testimony. She feels the pressure to testify perfectly. The trial begins on Monday, March 14, 2016. Miller describes what occurs each day of the trial, including the jury selection process. She meets with her childhood friend Athena, who is also a fellow survivor. She shares the truth about the assault with Athena and finds comfort and support.
Lucas returns to California to testify. Miller contemplates the effect her assault has had on him. She notes how he often chooses to go for a run after witnessing Miller “screaming, dissociating, leaving the apartment, crying under the covers, in the shower, whenever the case [is] brought up” (155). She drops Lucas off to testify the next morning. Tiffany arrives later that night. Miller finally feels ready to review the transcripts in preparation for her testimony.
The next day, Miller arrives at the courthouse to testify. After waiting two hours, Miller is called to the courtroom. Miller documents her testimony by including Alaleh’s questions in italics. The beginning of the direct examination moves seamlessly. When they reach the moment of Miller’s blackout, she grows emotional once again. She powers through the next few questions before unleashing the full torrent of her emotions when describing the confusion of that evening. Miller is again presented with photographs she has never seen that depict the state of her body on the evening of the assault. She finishes her direct examination and is scheduled to resume cross-examination.
Cross-examination begins on Monday. Like the hearing, it ends abruptly and leaves Miller questioning “if [she] did well or ruined [her] credibility” (181). Miller picks up Tiffany to drive her to the courthouse for her testimony later that afternoon. Later that evening, Tiffany receives a call from Alaleh and becomes upset. Alaleh informs her that the defense was using Tiffany’s testimony “to argue that when Brock found [her] he had every reason to think [she] was fine” (186). Miller sees through the defense’s tactics and understands the nature of the trial as “not a quest for justice but a test of endurance” (187). Seeing her sister’s pain, Miller grows angry.
The trial continues as Miller awaits updates on its developments. She watches the news and hears about Turner’s testimony, which claims she consented to the assault. Miller also details the testimony of four character witnesses brought in for Turner. She calls out the hypocrisy of this; she as the victim was denied the ability to defend her own character even though “[her] character was just as much on trial as his character; [her] behavior, [her] composure, [her] likability, were also being evaluated” (193).
Closing statements begin and Miller chooses to attend in person. She watches as Alaleh delivers a cogent and well-organized closing statement that leaves Miller fighting “the urge to applaud” (198). Turner’s defense attorney “deliver[s] an unconvincing monologue” that seems “as if he himself had been questioning his own arguments” (200). Miller returns home and awaits the verdict. As she waits, an article almost reveals her identity. Miller grows increasingly paranoid: She “trusted no one, could not escape the pervasive sense of invasion” (202).
Two days later, Miller is notified that the jury has reached a verdict. She alerts her family and friends and rushes to the courthouse. Turner is found guilty of all three counts of felony assault. Though expecting to feel triumphant, Miller sits “in sadness, inhaling wet air, [her] eyes closed, [her] chest shaking” (207). In this moment she realizes how little she cared for Emily and, ultimately, herself.
Turner is allowed to return to his family until the sentencing two months later. Miller hugs Alaleh and takes two envelopes from her. She calls Lucas with the verdict and drives home feeling “entirely new. [Like] [s]omething has been peeled off, [and] [she is] glowing” (210). Miller books “the first flight to Philly in the morning, eager to be Chanel again” (210). She finally opens the envelopes given to her by Alaleh. She finds two cards from supporters and feels empowered to begin the next step of her journey.
As Miller recounts the events of the trial, she criticizes the legal process for survivors, who face immense pressure on the witness stand. Miller discusses the gendered double standards that require female survivors to present themselves carefully during witness testimony to escape judgment: “[I]f you’re angry, you’re defensive. If you’re flat, you’re apathetic. Too upbeat, you’re suspect. If you weep, you’re hysterical” (149). When considering this pressure, she asks herself, “How should I balance it all?” (149). In addition to the emotional burden of reliving the details of their trauma and facing their assailants, survivors like Miller also carry the burden of these gendered stereotypes.
Miller organizes this chapter by the days of the trial. Presented as a journal, Miller chronicles the major testimonies and updates She details the emotional toll the trial has on her and her loved ones. After avoiding reviewing them, Miller finally returns to the transcripts of the investigation. She uses present tense when describing each event. As she reads, she states, “I am at the rape clinic” (157). For survivors, she suggests, to recall these traumatic moments is to relive them. This is an active process that leads to “the erasure of self, the unbecoming,” and Miller knows that “even after [she]’d leave […] [her] mind would stay there a long time, depleted for weeks” (159). The emotional impact of the legal process is one that is unavoidable for survivors and further highlights how the process does not center survivors and their well-being.
Once on the witness stand and facing her rapist, Miller abandons the pressure to stay composed. She allows herself to unleash the true overpowering wave of emotions that she, like many other survivors, are required to hide in their pursuit of justice. In this moment of empowerment through vulnerability, Miller decides, “Calm, collected, centered, strong, bullshit. I abandoned all of it, had no intention of stopping, had lost the little voice that told me to reel it in, could only think release, release, release” (166). This is a conscious choice that Miller makes. In these moments of empowered vulnerability, Miller finds freedom.
Through this trial, Miller grows increasingly aware of the inequalities faced by survivors in the criminal justice system. She observes the way the defense uses her sister Tiffany’s testimony to create “distorted realities, [their] words twisted until [they] became uncertain, discredited, writing [them]selves off as flawed and broken” (186). She emphasizes the impact of these tactics on survivors and their loved ones, who become consumed by self-doubt as the defense and media constantly call their characters into question. Survivors like Miller are unable to defend themselves or to paint a picture of their whole selves within the legal process. Miller underscores how this dehumanization leaves survivors vulnerable, with “nothing to suggest that [she] was a person extracted from a full life, surrounded by people who cared about [her]” (193).
Surprisingly, Turner’s guilty verdict leaves Miller overwhelmed with a sense of sadness, as she realizes in this moment the amount of self-doubt and blame she had placed on herself. She speaks directly to Emily, her self-appointed, dissociated self that carries the weight of her trauma. She apologizes to Emily and ultimately to herself as she proclaims, “You were not crazy” (208). Miller shifts from the second to the first person as she acknowledges the harm she has done to herself: “I believed I needed permission to return to my life, waiting for validation. I promised myself I would never question whether I deserved better” (208). Miller mourns the fact that she needed this verdict to validate what she inherently knew: that she was not to blame for her rape and that she deserves better.
As she completes this journey towards greater self-love and self-compassion, Miller feels connected to a greater community of survivors. She reads the letters Alaleh gives her after the trial and realizes that she is “surrounded by survivors. [She] was part of a we” (212). This realization furthers Miller’s pursuit of a higher purpose to connect with and advocate for other survivors. She now sees herself as “the leader on the front line fighting, with an entire infantry behind [her]” (212). Though the trial centers around the moment Miller became a victim, its ending focuses on the moment Miller becomes a leader.
Plus, gain access to 8,800+ more expert-written Study Guides.
Including features:
Art
View Collection
Asian American & Pacific Islander...
View Collection
Feminist Reads
View Collection
Inspiring Biographies
View Collection
National Book Critics Circle Award...
View Collection
New York Times Best Sellers
View Collection
True Crime & Legal
View Collection
Women's Studies
View Collection