91 pages • 3 hours read
A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more. For select classroom titles, we also provide Teaching Guides with discussion and quiz questions to prompt student engagement.
Méndez creates a rich backdrop for Camila’s story by setting the narrative in modern-day Rosario. As an Argentine American who was raised in Argentina, Méndez offers an insider’s perspective of the culture and community yet is able to mark the contrasts between Argentinian culture and American culture to show her readers the qualities that make the Argentinian people unique.
The setting comes alive through Méndez’s use of specific street names, park names, and landmarks. Méndez grew up in barrio 7 de Septiembre, the same in which Camila lives in the novel. Within Camila’s barrio, Méndez characterizes the neighbors as nosy yet also conveys a sense of closeness in the neighborhood. Camila and Diego know the neighborhood kids by name, and although gossip runs rampant, the community gathers at the end of the novel to see Camila off to the United States. Descriptions of Camila’s neighborhood and the surrounding city of Rosario provide a rich sense of place for the events of the novel and give the reader a taste of the communal atmosphere in Argentina.
Méndez also peppers the narrative with subtle references to aspects of the culture such as food, physical touch, and language. Camila’s mother makes several cultural dishes such as milanesas (fried breaded steak) and fugazza con queso (Argentinian focaccia). Pastries, called facturas, also feature as a staple item in Argentinian culture. Diego and Camila stop at a bakery a few times, and Camila’s mother shares facturas with Camila at home. Finally, perhaps the most commonly mentioned aspect of Argentinian food culture in the novel is mate, a tea made from dried leaves. Making and sharing mate is a common social practice in Argentina and other South American countries, much like drinking coffee in the United States. Along with mentions of cultural food and drink, Mendez also describes the Argentinian practice of greeting a friend with a kiss on the cheek. Although this would be considered an intimate gesture in some cultures, for Argentinians, it is a normal salutation. Physical touch is mentioned a few other places in the novel as Camila touches Diego’s arm, hair, and neck in a casual way. Although these instances of physical touch serve to heighten the sexual tension between the couple, Méndez also uses them to show the commonality of physical closeness in the culture. Finally, Méndez includes many Spanish words throughout the narrative to incorporate the national language into her narrative. Food, physical touch, and language contribute to the novel’s setting and educate readers on the practices and foods of Argentina.
On a more serious note, Méndez also depicts the dangers of life in Rosario because of the crime and poverty present there. Fear of theft and kidnapping is shown to be an ever-present concern for Camila. As a young woman, she is especially vulnerable. Anything of value, such as Camila’s expensive phone or Diego’s BMW, is shown to be target for thieves, and posters of missing girls fill the walls at the bus stop. The kidnapping and murder of Eda is a sobering example of the all-too-common rapes, kidnappings, and killings in the community. Sadly, many people, such as Camila’s father, blame the victim for “running with the wrong crowd” (305). However, Méndez shows that many people are fighting against this mentality. Camila marches with her team to demand justice for Eda, emphasizing the changing societal mentality surrounding the dangers and injustice present in the community.
Méndez highlights the gender inequality present in Argentina through the events of the novel, describing the adversity Camila faces because of her gender. She shows that women’s rights have improved, and gradually continue to improve, but still have a long way to go towards equality. Although Méndez mentions organized movements such as Ni Una Menos, she shows that progress made at the level of individual women is just as powerful, if not more powerful, than the progress of organizations. Even though Camila is not a consistent or primary participant in a women’s rights organization, she impacts the culture’s mindset towards women simply by pursuing her dream of playing professional soccer.
Camila experiences sexism at both the societal level and the family level. She struggles to reconcile her dreams of becoming a futbolera with the opportunities available to her. According to the traditional Argentine mindset, girls shouldn’t play soccer past puberty—it’s considered a masculine sport. However, Camila defies this element of cultural sexism by secretly playing on a women’s team with the goal of eventually going pro. The team unites her with other women who push back against societal expectations, and the team—including Coach Alicia—provides encouragement and solidarity in Camila’s pursuit of her dreams and battle against sexism.
Méndez depicts the way the cultural mentality towards women plays out at the family level and easily passes from one generation to the next. Camila’s father values women for their appearance, not for their talents, and Pablo shows tendencies towards this mentality as well. Even Camila’s mother comments on Camila’s physical appearance, showing how easily this view of women is perpetuated—even by women who have been victims of sexism themselves.
Furthermore, Méndez uses the history of El Buen Pastor to chronicle the sexism that has plagued Argentina for decades and to parallel the inequalities of the present day. Although women are no longer imprisoned, they are devalued and sometimes silenced by society, and they do not receive equal opportunities as men. Mendez also shows how other women are affected by the gender inequalities present in the culture. Marisa, Eda, and Camila’s mother all feature as examples of women who have been victims of gender inequality.
When Camila marches with Ni Una Menos for Eda, the reader sees her speak up for women’s rights in a public way. However, Méndez shows that Camila’s greatest contribution to the cause of gender equality is on a personal level: she pursues her dreams at all costs, without letting sexism stop her. Playing soccer is Camila’s way of standing up for women and challenging the culture. She might not be able to change an entire system on her own, but she can change her own life. Camila can be true to herself even when others don’t see her value, and in the process, she can inspire other women and young girls to do the same.
Méndez creates complex relationships among Camila’s family members to direct the plot’s movement and to highlight the influence of family in one’s life. Although she feels a strong connection to her ancestors, Camila seems to have distanced herself from her immediate family as she’s grown older. Not only does she keep secrets from them, but she also feels emotionally disconnected from them. Her family doesn’t know about the most important part of her life: playing soccer. Furthermore, Camila knows that they would not understand or support her dream based on their mentality towards women in society. Méndez explains that this wall between Camila and her family developed as Camila became a young woman. On multiple occasions, Camila describes that a change took place after puberty in how she related to her parents. Whereas she used to be “perfect and beloved” before her body changed (120), she is now the object of her father’s criticism, as well as a “business investment” in his eyes (122). Her relationship with her mother is also strained as her mom takes out her own sadness and insecurity on Camila. Even Pablo, who always used to encourage Camila and knows her secret, changes because of the pressure he faces as a Central player and sounds more like their father every day.
As the plot develops, Méndez describes the shifting dynamics among Camila’s family relationships. Camila finally opens up to her mother about her dream of playing soccer, and although her mother’s response is mixed, she eventually comes around to supporting Camila wholeheartedly. Even though sharing her secret meant opening herself up to further hurt and adversity, Camila takes the risk and is rewarded in time with a closer relationship with her mother than she’s ever experienced. Camila’s dynamic with her father also changes. Tension builds throughout the novel and finally culminates at the novel’s climax, when Camila stands up to her father and he becomes violent. As her family relationships shift, so does Camila’s life. The novel’s resolution shows that after being arrested, Camila’s father no longer holds power over her or her future; he is out of the picture. Furthermore, Camila now has her mother’s support as she pursues her dreams in Utah. She and Pablo’s relationship blooms as well, as Pablo is out from under their father’s control.
Although Camila is characterized as fiercely independent, Méndez shows that she cannot simply separate her life from her family; they are an inescapable part of her identity. The changes that occur in her relationships with her mother, father, and brother are due in large part to Camila’s choices: She bravely tells her mother the truth about playing soccer and stands up to her father. Although the road was not easy, Camila’s actions sparked positive changes for herself, her mother, and Pablo. Méndez not only emphasizes the inescapable influence of family in one’s life, but also shows that familial relationships have the capacity for change. For Camila, small choices lead to transformational shifts within her family.
Plus, gain access to 8,800+ more expert-written Study Guides.
Including features:
Books that Feature the Theme of...
View Collection
Diverse Voices (High School)
View Collection
Equality
View Collection
Family
View Collection
Hispanic & Latinx American Literature
View Collection
Realistic Fiction (High School)
View Collection
Reese Witherspoon's Hello Sunshine...
View Collection
Romance
View Collection
The Best of "Best Book" Lists
View Collection